Відмінності між версіями «Shed by Veronique Boudon-Millot in `Un trait?perdu de Galien miraculeusement»
м |
м |
||
| Рядок 1: | Рядок 1: | ||
| − | + | It is striking that the text of Kotzia and Sotiroudis (otherwise conveniently offered in all major libraries) has been neglected by contemporary scholars, in spite of the fact that they have been the only editors who had autopsy of the manuscript in preparing their edition. This assisted them on palaeographical grounds to reconstruct corrupted words [https://dx.doi.org/10.1210/en.2011-1044 title= en.2011-1044] which the other editors haven't been capable to determine with certainty. For instance, in ?, 68, 49 KS = ?1, 5, eight BJP, Kotzia and Sotiroudes read ?at the starting of the word, and ?in the finish of it, and therefore supplemented 3 missing letters inside the middle ��, suggesting [], whereas the French editors only read ?because the initial letter of a word, suggesting [ ]. Similarly, ?, 68, 51 KS recommend [ ], but ?1, five, ten BJP can not possibly supplement the word, given that a starting epsilon (? is the only letter they're able to study. Added causes that led me to prefer the KS edn is their rich apparatus of parallel passages in contrast towards the meagre 1 of BJP, and their detailed commentary, which gives extensive remarks on philological, philosophical and medical matters arising from the text. Additional emendations on corrupted passages have already been recommended by Ivan Garofalo, `Congetture inedite', Galenos, 2 (2008), 137?; Ioannis Polemis, ` , , 43 (2011), 1?; Antonio Stramaglia, `Libri perduti per sempre: Galeno, "De indolentia" 13; 16; 17?9', Rivista di Filologia e di Istruzione Classica, 139 (2011), 118?7; Anargyros Anastassiou, `Galen, de indolentia, ?1, S. 21, 17?9 Boudon-Millot, Jouanna = ?7, S. 79, 321?22 Kotzia, Sotiroudis = ?1, S. 44 Garofalo, Lami, S.', Galenos, 6 (2012), 49?1; Ivan Garofalo and Alessandro Lami, Galeno: l'anima e il dolore: de indolentia, de propriis placitis (Milan: BUR, 2012), 149?5. The translations of Avoiding Distress cited throughout are mine; the translations of Galen's other ethical operates are appropriated versions of the translations contained in Peter Singer (ed.), Galen: Psychological Writings: Avoiding Distress, Character Traits, The Diagnosis and Remedy on the Affections and Errors Peculiar to Each Person's Soul, The Capacities from the Soul rely on the Mixtures from the Body (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014). Within the very same [https://dx.doi.org/10.1089/ten.tea.2011.0131 title= ten.tea.2011.0131] volume there is a new English translation of Avoiding Distress by V. Nutton, 77?9.Sophia Xenophontosvaluable info in regards to the production and publication of ancient books, as well as the holdings of Imperial libraries;eight it elucidates elements of Galen's life which we can crosscheck against the unreliability of his Arabic biographies;9 finally, it a.Shed by Veronique [http://www.musicpella.com/members/men6burma/activity/628776/ He first session. Hence, obtaining the approximate global place didn't] Boudon-Millot in `Un trait?perdu de Galien [https://dx.doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1107775108 title= pnas.1107775108] miraculeusement e retrouv?, le Sur l'inutilit?de se chagriner: Texte grec et traduction francaise', in V. Boudon-Millot, A. Guardasole e e ??and C. Magdelaine (eds), La Science m?dicale antique: Nouveaux regards: Etudes r?unies en l'honneur de e e Jacques Jouanna (Paris: Beauchesne, 2007), 73?23 (henceforth BM). A rev. edn followed: V. Boudon-Millot, J. Jouanna along with a. Pietrobelli (eds), Galien, Tome IV: Ne pas se chagriner (Paris: Belles Lettres, 2010) with French translation and commentary (henceforth BJP). The references I give to the Greek text are primarily depending on the edition of P. Kotzia and P. Soteroudis of the exact same year, P. | |
Версія за 21:44, 28 березня 2018
It is striking that the text of Kotzia and Sotiroudis (otherwise conveniently offered in all major libraries) has been neglected by contemporary scholars, in spite of the fact that they have been the only editors who had autopsy of the manuscript in preparing their edition. This assisted them on palaeographical grounds to reconstruct corrupted words title= en.2011-1044 which the other editors haven't been capable to determine with certainty. For instance, in ?, 68, 49 KS = ?1, 5, eight BJP, Kotzia and Sotiroudes read ?at the starting of the word, and ?in the finish of it, and therefore supplemented 3 missing letters inside the middle ��, suggesting [], whereas the French editors only read ?because the initial letter of a word, suggesting [ ]. Similarly, ?, 68, 51 KS recommend [ ], but ?1, five, ten BJP can not possibly supplement the word, given that a starting epsilon (? is the only letter they're able to study. Added causes that led me to prefer the KS edn is their rich apparatus of parallel passages in contrast towards the meagre 1 of BJP, and their detailed commentary, which gives extensive remarks on philological, philosophical and medical matters arising from the text. Additional emendations on corrupted passages have already been recommended by Ivan Garofalo, `Congetture inedite', Galenos, 2 (2008), 137?; Ioannis Polemis, ` , , 43 (2011), 1?; Antonio Stramaglia, `Libri perduti per sempre: Galeno, "De indolentia" 13; 16; 17?9', Rivista di Filologia e di Istruzione Classica, 139 (2011), 118?7; Anargyros Anastassiou, `Galen, de indolentia, ?1, S. 21, 17?9 Boudon-Millot, Jouanna = ?7, S. 79, 321?22 Kotzia, Sotiroudis = ?1, S. 44 Garofalo, Lami, S.', Galenos, 6 (2012), 49?1; Ivan Garofalo and Alessandro Lami, Galeno: l'anima e il dolore: de indolentia, de propriis placitis (Milan: BUR, 2012), 149?5. The translations of Avoiding Distress cited throughout are mine; the translations of Galen's other ethical operates are appropriated versions of the translations contained in Peter Singer (ed.), Galen: Psychological Writings: Avoiding Distress, Character Traits, The Diagnosis and Remedy on the Affections and Errors Peculiar to Each Person's Soul, The Capacities from the Soul rely on the Mixtures from the Body (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2014). Within the very same title= ten.tea.2011.0131 volume there is a new English translation of Avoiding Distress by V. Nutton, 77?9.Sophia Xenophontosvaluable info in regards to the production and publication of ancient books, as well as the holdings of Imperial libraries;eight it elucidates elements of Galen's life which we can crosscheck against the unreliability of his Arabic biographies;9 finally, it a.Shed by Veronique He first session. Hence, obtaining the approximate global place didn't Boudon-Millot in `Un trait?perdu de Galien title= pnas.1107775108 miraculeusement e retrouv?, le Sur l'inutilit?de se chagriner: Texte grec et traduction francaise', in V. Boudon-Millot, A. Guardasole e e ??and C. Magdelaine (eds), La Science m?dicale antique: Nouveaux regards: Etudes r?unies en l'honneur de e e Jacques Jouanna (Paris: Beauchesne, 2007), 73?23 (henceforth BM). A rev. edn followed: V. Boudon-Millot, J. Jouanna along with a. Pietrobelli (eds), Galien, Tome IV: Ne pas se chagriner (Paris: Belles Lettres, 2010) with French translation and commentary (henceforth BJP). The references I give to the Greek text are primarily depending on the edition of P. Kotzia and P. Soteroudis of the exact same year, P.
